Donald Trump Reverses Course, Signs an Executive Order to Stop Separating Families

Print Share on LinkedIn Comments More

Ivan Pierre Aguirre for The Texas Tribune

Temporary housing holds detained children in Tornillo, Texas.

After days of outcry, the Trump administration has backed off of a contentious new policy that separated more than 2,000 immigrant children from their parents who crossed the border illegally.

And, it seems, he has the Republican-dominated Congress behind him: On Wednesday afternoon, as the president signed an executive order halting those separations, top Senate Republicans introduced a bill that would achieve much the same goals.

Both the order and the legislation are designed to address the consequences of Trump’s policy of criminally prosecuting all illegal border crossers without relaxing the policy itself. Under the administration’s “zero tolerance” policy, when parents cross the border illegally, their children are taken from them because they cannot be sent to jails.

The order directs that “to the extent permitted by law,” immigrant families should be held together in immigration detention facilities run by the Department of Homeland Security. Trump said the order will end the family separations while prosecutions continue. The decision to keep children – some reportedly as young as 8 months old – away from their parents and under the care of strangers has drawn strong rebukes from lawmakers, religious leaders and immigration advocates across the country.

“We’re going to have strong, very strong borders, but we’re going to keep the families together,” Trump said.

Meanwhile, Senate Republicans – including both U.S. senators from Texas – introduced the Keep Families Together and Enforce the Law Act, which would hold families together in detention centers run by the Department of Homeland Security as they await a court hearing. That would effectively give the administration the best of both worlds: a strict immigration process without the family separations that have earned near-universal backlash.

“A zero tolerance policy is exactly correct, I think a family reunification policy is exactly correct,” U.S. Sen. John Cornyn told reporters Wednesday.

The executive and legislative measures are geared toward the same goal. But, Cornyn said, congressional action is necessary because “there probably will be legal challenges to the president’s executive order.”

“It’s important to have the backstop of congressional action to be able to preserve this family unity goal,” said Cornyn, who is among the most powerful Republicans in Congress.

The executive order seems to put Trump squarely at odds with a 1997 legal constraint, known as the Flores settlement, which says children may not be detained for more than 20 days, even if they are with their parents. That had kept President Barack Obama from keeping families together in detention centers during a similar immigration surge.

In the order, Trump directs Attorney General Jeff Sessions to work to “modify” that settlement agreement to permit the government “to detain alien families together throughout the pendency of criminal proceedings for improper entry or any removal or other immigration proceedings.”

The executive order also represents a sharp departure from the administration’s previous position, a reversal that seems to have been prompted by a flood of public outcry over the last several days.

Facing widespread, harsh criticism from both sides of the aisle and all corners of the country, Trump at first defended the policy by saying he was simply following the law and insisted, incorrectly, that only Congress could stop the separations.

Under past administrations, most first-time border crossers had not been criminally prosecuted for illegally entering the country.

Even in Texas, where prominent Republicans tend to hew to the Trump line, many statewide Republican leaders, including Gov. Greg Abbott and both of the state’s U.S. senators, had been calling for ending the separations.

Abby Livingston and Claire Parker contributed reporting from Washington.

5 thoughts on “Donald Trump Reverses Course, Signs an Executive Order to Stop Separating Families

  1. Trump and his followers are vile, horrible people. The fact that there are people DEFENDING him is unbelievable. “I don’t agree with separating families, but…” I can’t even. Especially when those supporters claim to be Christians. It’s completely nauseating.

    • You know the whole Reno vs Flores case in which Flores was a LIBERAL who was saying it was inhumane to place children in holding cells with their parents and other adults that were waiting for their proceedings. The Flores settlement in 1997 is the agreement to place kids in more appropriate holdings in accordance to their age or special needs while their parents were awaiting their court hearings

  2. I wonder if you were as outraged when it was 42-44 that was doing this? Most of the images that have been submitted, including the introduction image to this email link were from 44’s time in office. What you fail to acknowledge is that 2/3’s of the incoming “children” are unaccompanied or accompanied by a person other than a family member. These facilities are providing clean safe living and sleeping arrangements, clean clothes, full bellies and medical for all that are coming in, some that have been lack these things for a long time, or if they even ever had it in their lives to begin with . THESE are the lucky ones. The unlucky ones are the ones who are handed back over to the traffickers claiming to be family members. The unlucky ones are the ones who are left in the desert because they became a greater liability than an asset. The unlucky ones are never head from again. The unlucky ones disappear in the sex trafficking trade. When living in Nashville, I worked with a guy from southern Mexico that traveled up there looking for his sister who was stolen and trafficked up there years previously. This was back in 2001. I get tired of seeing the comparison to Nazi death camps and even the Japanese concentration camps, and they are NOTHING like those camps. And you would do well to remember that.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *