Lack of Criminal Justice is Stifling Mexico’s Growth

Print Share on LinkedIn Comments More
The National Palace is the seat of the federal executive in Mexico. It is located on Mexico City's main square, the Plaza de la Constitución. Courtesy photo.

The National Palace is the seat of the federal executive in Mexico. It is located on Mexico City's main square, the Plaza de la Constitución. Courtesy photo.

Over the past 18 months, I’ve written about the extraordinary changes taking place across Mexico, including its impressive reform agenda, growing high-tech sectordynamic supply chains, and deepening regional integration. Yet to achieve Mexico’s and North America’s full potential will require moving forward on a number of key challenges, the most pressing of which is rule of law.

Mexico influence poll_Pew Research Center 2014There are many reasons why Mexico’s leadership should care about rule of law, but most important is simply that it is one of the top concerns of Mexicans across the country. Last year, more than 50%of Mexicans reported feeling unfavorably about the country’s court system, and these effects spill over in damaging ways. One visible sign is the low number of crimes that are reported, with government estimates suggesting that each year more than 90% of crimes never make it onto the official books. Of those that do, only 15% are ever investigated.

Last September’s shocking disappearance of 43 students in Guerrero was perhaps the highest-profile example of Mexico’s weak rule of law. The event and the corruption it exposed frayed Mexicans’ trust in their public institutions, rocking the country and drawing tens of thousands of protestors onto the streets. When the Casa Blanca scandal broke soon after, revealing that the first lady owned a $7 million house registered to a company whose owner had just won a multi-billion dollar high-speed train concession, it merely compounded the frustration.

Without a solid rule of law foundation, government officials seem aware that they could be building their economic policy architecture upon shaky ground. In the past weeks, members of the administration have promised change, with President Peña Nieto pledging to pick up the fight against corruption and Luis Videgaray claiming that rule of law was “worth ten energy reforms.” Agustín Carstens, Mexico’s Central Banker, also chimed in, calling rule of law “tremendously important.”

The country’s oft-discussed 2008 judicial reform provides the most apparent avenue for improving rule of law. The reform promised to move Mexico’s judiciary to an oral, adversarial system and guarantee certain rights for the accused. Yet, progress to date hasn’t been encouraging. Depending on who is doing the measuring and how, there have been either zero or three states fully internalizing all of the reform’s components.

To be fair, this type of overhaul is excruciatingly difficult. A judicial system is very much a country’s invisible plumbing, and uprooting and overhauling it often means breaking down more walls than originally expected. It means retraining legal staff (judges, lawyers, and prosecutors), rewriting textbooks, and retrofitting courtrooms, among the many adjustments —with the total bill estimated to come in at around $4.2 billion. While a sizable amount, it bears remembering that this is far less than the price tag that comes annually from the country’s weak rule of law.

It is also worth reminding ourselves that while improving rule of law can feel overwhelming, there are examples of countries — like Singapore — that tackled pervasive corruption and emerged victorious.

Further, President Peña Nieto’s government has already shown its political capabilities and willingness to take on entrenched and vested interests in its economic reform agenda. If the administration should choose to apply this same commitment and resolve to tackle rule of law, implementation would surely pick up the pace.

The international community is watching Mexico’s next moves, including the many investors who are looking for new opportunities. But the eyes that matter most are those of Mexicans living in the country today; expecting better, deserving better, and hoping to see better.


This story was originally published on Antonio Garza’s blog here.

*Featured/top image: The National Palace is the seat of the federal executive in Mexico. It is located on Mexico City’s main square, the Plaza de la Constitución. Courtesy photo.

Related Stories:

Vicente Fox: Energy Reform Will Bring American Dream to Mexico

San Antonio: Bridge City to Mexico

Can Mexico’s New President Open Long-Closed Energy Sector?

Rackspace Opens for Business in Mexico City

9 thoughts on “Lack of Criminal Justice is Stifling Mexico’s Growth

  1. I must have an old paper about this, from my years at junior high. That means, same’ol same’ol.

    The idea was to probe how impossible it was to implement “Law and Order” in Mexican mentality due to “historical dissidence” specially in my generation, pledged with “Anarchism”, “Criminal Society” and “Criminal Socialism”.

  2. The problem is the “good” side of the Law, worldwide, doesn’t want to cure the problem of the “war of drugs.” They just want to treat the problem, much like the medical industry doesn’t want to cure diseases, there’s no money in cures. The money is in the treatment. It’s amazing that Venezuela is not a US ally, yet they have cocaine cartels too; but virtually no cocaine from Venezuela enters the US. Just like Colombia, but Colombia is a US ally, and most all cocaine that enters the US originates from Colombia. Coincidence or was engineered like that? A lot of problems from crime in Mexico stem from the US because that’s where all the cartels make their money(their money gives them power and influence); the good ol’USA the most lucrative illicit drug market on the planet. Back on to the LE aspect, what if the this “drug war” was over on Monday? Well if it was there would no longer be a need for the DEA, Narcotics units in PDs&SOs, most DHS would no longer be necessary, no more drug task forces; most importantly no more Government spending fighting this drug war. Which would put a huge damper on the economy; if you read into the facts this black market economy is apart of the whole world economy, whether you like it or not.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *