Where the Millennials Worship in San Antonio

Print Share on LinkedIn Comments More
Doug Robbins leads a worship service at City Church Downtown. Courtesy photo.

Doug Robbins leads a worship service for City Church Downtown during Easter Service at Sunset Station. Courtesy photo.

Depending on who you ask, the generation known as Millennials has a problematic relationship with evangelical Christian church. Some more than others may claim that the situation is dire, but most agree that at least a certain subset of the generation is disappearing from church rolls. Among the young, educated, urban professionals, church affiliation is historically low on their priority list.

Faith, however, is a different matter. Harder to measure, faith, even faith in Jesus Christ is less and less essentially tied to church membership. Especially for Millennials, whose inherent iconoclasm and anti-institutional tendencies make them leery of attendance keeping, capital campaigns, and 50-year plans.

Fr. William Eavenson, Jr. serves as the lead pastor for student ministry at The Mission Chattanooga in Tennessee. He’s devoted the past 10 years to ministering to his own generation, and seen considerable fruit where many have struggled to gain traction.

William Eavenson leads a prayer service in Chattanooga, Tenn. Courtesy photo.

Fr. William Eavenson Jr. leads a prayer service in Chattanooga, Tenn. Courtesy photo.

“Millennials reject a Church that to us seems outdated, overly political, anti-homosexual, anti-science, doubtless, power and cash obsessed and generally hypocritical. We like and in many cases even love Jesus and want to know and maybe even follow Him, but refuse to believe we have to take on the vestiges of cultural religion in order to do so,” Eavenson said.

As the population of city center young professionals continues to grow in San Antonio, several Christian pastors have found deep resonance with the passions, skepticism, and concerns of the educated, professional 18-35 demographic. The very demographic that seems to be vacating the pews of their parents’ churches is flocking to their authenticity, generosity, and tangibility.

These pastors seem to look at the state of the Christian faith with prophetic eyes. Prophetic in sense of the Biblical Old Testament prophets. Some see the Millennial generation as a wake up call to the institutional church.

In a study conducted by the Barna Group, only 30% of Millennials of any faith felt that church was very important. Most evangelical pastors would probably support those statistics, as they try to figure out how to minister to this huge and increasingly unchurched population.

For the pastors whose ministries are filled with active, passionate Millennials, there is little disconnect between the generation and the Christian faith. In fact, they’ve found that by speaking to the needs, hang-ups and quirks of many Millennials they are able love the disillusioned, forgotten, and hurting of every generation. Which is a lot like the Jesus they keep talking about. 

Doug Robbins is the pastor of City Church Downtown. It’s immediately obvious why Millennials are drawn to his ministry.

“I’m not trying to reach Millennials,” Robbins said.

In 2008 Robbins felt called by God to start a church downtown. City Church Downtown’s sister campuses, Bandera Road City Church and City Church West look like the communities they serve on the northwest and far west of San Antonio, respectively. Robbins wanted the downtown campus to reflect its neighborhood as well. Since they meet at the Cameo Theater in St. Paul Square, the crowd is diverse. As the church’s website proudly proclaims, “We welcome everyone from bikers to bankers, PhD’s to G.E.D.’s, hipsters to homeless, blue collar, white collar, and a few who wear dog collars.”

Doug Robbins leads a worship service at City Church Downtown. Courtesy photo.

Doug Robbins leads a worship service at City Church Downtown. Courtesy photo.

When visitors arrive on Sunday morning, they may or may not realize that the usher greeting them at the door falls in and out of homelessness. But they won’t see someone who looks like them strategically placed to make them feel comfortable.

The church, which is 70% minority and multi-generational appeals to real San Antonio, not a target demographic. Diversity means that social justice and healing, key values of the Millennial generation, are a necessary component of the ministry.

“There aren’t enough hipsters to fill a church. Why not love the people who are here?” Robbins said.

Well, hipsters love that. Young people love that. Hurt people love that. People of all ages who don’t fit into the shiny, polite churches of the 20th century love that. Millennials crave authenticity, which, by definition, can’t be manufactured.

So Robbins keeps loving the people around him, and the crowd keeps growing. 

The homegrown appeal is another key to the Millennial puzzle. The generation that loves to eat and buy “local” also loves to worship that way. They don’t seek stability in the establishment or name brand franchises. Quite the opposite, in fact.

Drew Witt’s ministry, The Gathering Church, almost feels like an underground network. Their Sunday worship gathering in the Star Storage Facility (the former Borden Milk Plant) is not easy to find. Few do so without a personal invitation.

Drew Witt

Drew Witt

Fortunately for Witt, who calls himself “the reluctant church planter,” the ministry is made up of some of the most passionate people in downtown. By relying on word of mouth and relationships to bring people to the church, The Gathering Church emphasizes connectivity over publicity or programming.

That is intentional on Witt’s part. When he felt God moving him toward the River North area four years ago, he had no intention of starting a church.

“The last thing San Antonio needs is another church service,” he said, recalling his thoughts at the time.

So they didn’t start a church, in the traditional sense. They started meeting people and listening to them. From his graphic design/videography office at Geekdom, Witt watched as a network of people formed around he and his wife, and eventually began worshipping together on Sundays.

“We didn’t want to start a church, we just wanted to serve people,” Witt said.

To that end, he’s kept his ministry “light weight and low maintenance.” Rather than imposing a calendar of committees and church events, Witt encourages people to do stuff with the people in their neighborhoods and workplaces. Theologically, he’s commissioning them to go live like Jesus in their ordinary lives. Practically, he’s freeing them up to invest in the activities that mean something to them. Kickball, beer nights, Habitat for Humanity, whatever it is.

Cynthia Phelps sits with fellow Geekdom member Drew Witt in the new Geekdom kitchen on opening day at the Rand Building. Photo by Iris Dimmick.

Cynthia Phelps sits with fellow Geekdom member Drew Witt in the co-working space’s kitchen on opening day at the Rand Building. Photo by Iris Dimmick.

For Millennials, whose lives are packed with vocational, relational, and recreational activity this model works. Millennials love purpose. They love finding fulfillment in their jobs, friends, and volunteering. Rather than replacing that with church activity, Witt blesses their activity and commissions them to do it like Jesus would.

Far from eschewing history and rootedness, people in their 20s are looking for exactly that. The institutions of their parents and grandparents may have disappointed them, but so has the internet. They want something to hold on to, that still looks like the original. The original here being Jesus.

“Everything in our world is cheap and disposable. A faith that is ancient, transcendent, beautiful, proven true, and found meaningful through many times and places is compelling … it feeds the part of us that craves having causes to fight for in a way that is anti-consumerist,” Eavenson said.

Fr. William Eavenson (second from the left) leads a group of volunteers at a work day for Widow's Harvest Ministries. Courtesy photo.

Fr. William Eavenson (second from the left) leads a group of volunteers at a work day for Widow’s Harvest Ministries. Courtesy photo.

This has led many young adults who were raised in evangelical or main stream churches back to the ultra-tangible, high-church traditions like Catholicism and Orthodoxy.

Patrick Burnham, 26, fits this profile of a young urban professional perfectly. He lives in Dignowity Hill, works at Lake|Flato, and after growing up Baptist and nondenominational he now worships at St. Anthony the Great Eastern Orthodox Church.

“I love that my church is truly ancient, that it’s not trying to recreate or imitate how the early church worshipped and practiced their faith, because it is the uninterrupted continuation of that earliest church,” Burnham said.

The tangibility and history appeal to Burnham and other young converts to the ancient traditions, but within these practices they have also found a spirituality that appeals to their values.

“My church is a loving and compassionate community of sinners who love Christ and understand that each of us are still being healed by God. It is the safest and most peaceful place I’ve ever known, it is how I envision heaven,” Burnham said.

Millennials want authenticity, honesty, and compassion. They want to be led in how to care for the underserved and disenfranchised. They want to have real friendships with people outside their faith community. They want to know that when life’s storms come (and they are often still to come for the Millennials) that they won’t be alone. They want something that wasn’t invented by their grandparents.

That’s actually a lot like Biblical Christianity, the way Jesus did it.

*Featured/top image: Doug Robbins leads a worship service for City Church Downtown during Easter Service at Sunset Station. Courtesy photo.

Related Stories:

Millennial Philanthropy and Social Responsibility

Church Could Learn a Few Things From Poets

Something Monday: Historic Downtown Churches

Faith Convening: Connecting Church, Community to Schools

24 thoughts on “Where the Millennials Worship in San Antonio

  1. Those who are going into high church traditions are doing the opposite of what the beginning of the article states in that they don’t fit the profile of the “inherent iconoclasm and anti-institutional tendencies “. The high-church traditions are exactly that, traditional, institutional, and iconic. So while many millennials are unaffiliated and suspicious of organized church, or “churchiness,” in complete contrast, others are affiliating themselves with the historical, institutional, utterly traditional, established church.

  2. I disagree with this article completely. I’m a millennial and am rooted in a Christian church for over 15yrs now. Rooted means I’ve developed relationships with many of the members in the church. I have their numbers in my cell. I’ve gone to their houses. We know eachothers kids and stories of our triumphs and struggles. I cannot tell you how many times I went thru my hangups that my church friends were there in person and over the phone praying with me, ministering to me and reminding me to keep going. Many times I had personal one on one for hours to help me breakthrough. I backslide many times and would stop going to church for weeks. If it wasn’t for them loving me, following up on me, I would still be in the world. It is very important to build relationships in the church because we need to hold ourselves accountable to someone. Otherwise, we slip away. I welcome the phone calls and texts that ask me where were you today? Is everything ok can we pray with you? Millenials that don’t feel church attendance is important have missed the meaning of church. God is not confined to a building. He is everywhere. We go to church to worship together. We go to church to commune. We go to church to hear the group message God has for us as a church to keep us filled for the week. Church is about US, the body. I dislike churches that grab at the wallet. I tithe faithfully. A tithe is 10% of my earnings. That’s literally 100s of $ I GIVE, not pay, to my church because that’s me honoring God for all He’s done in my life. It is not a commandment and it is an old testament practice. In the new testament, the blessings of tithing come, and not the curses. I’ve never felt pressured to give my tithe in my church. In fact only 10% of people tithe in most churches. It took me years to realize the importance of tithing. And it’s not because anyone in my church or my pastor made me feel bad or put a guilt trip on me, it’s because I went to God in prayer and the light bulb went off on why I should tithe. Every since I started tithing faithfully, thousands of $$$ has flowed into my household supernaturally. I can’t help but connect the two. When you give 10%, God blesses your 90%.

    Also we welcome everyone to our church and taught to love people where they are at in their lives. Many times I have been attacked for my faith because people are judgemental towards me being a Christian. I tolerate alot, but that doesn’t mean I accept many things that don’t align with God’s word. Its great that these pastors are attracting people of all walks, but their message needs to be that we conform to God, and not God conform to us and our lifestyles. Many times we cater to the lost and wounded because we want them to go thru a healing process to come out of whatever they are in. To minister to people to keep on doing what they are doing is not the right message. We need to get to the root of why they showed up in the first place to see them delivered and serving others. This article I feel was contradicting itself.

    • Nicole,
      As I read the article it did trapped my attention however as I read more I notice exactly what you mentioned. God will change us and break us to a new person. Continue to doing the things of the world is not what God wants for us. I commend you on your comments and here to tell you to continue seeking him. We cant change those that are wrongly led. Praying and maintain a good testimony is what we are called to do.
      God bless you and keep you.

  3. We leave these institutions because they are no longer relevant. Religion is no longer relevant. There is more information available now than ever before, giving us more options and different perspectives.

    These ideas are old, and were needed for that time. It’s time for new ideas.

  4. Very interesting article. My own church, which also happens to be downtown, has attracted quite a few Millennials who want to follow Jesus without becoming entangled in obligation. Yet, when community forms, everyone ends up contributing.

  5. I think some group (the Hindus perhaps) got it generally correct when they connected human suffering with our human ability to see ourselves as separate from all else. Also, Modest Mouse hit it on the head when they said very succinctly that it’s hard to be a human being (Baby Blue Sedan, if you’re wondering).

  6. I have two adult nephews, one is a Dallas-based Yuppie/Gen X- hybrid and the younger one is a Millennial.
    GenX is successful and attends some kind of Bible based Christian church with his equally successful wife.
    The Millennial is a single, handsome ship’s captain in Florida, and I think the nearest beach might be his church.
    Neither are the type to attend a gigantic megachurch, or be swayed by a slick preacher.
    I think megachurches and their ministers are starting to turn people off. Joel Olsteen has a 100,000 square foot house. Why? I’d find it hard to drop a tenner in the basket at his church.
    Worse yet is San Antonio-based John Hagee and his mega empire Cornerstone church. The guy is a stumpy 300 pounder, who tells fat lady jokes from the pulpit. Also, he hates gays, hates liberals, hates Obama, ad nauseam. He pontificates and opines as though he has Jesus on his Bluetooth, prompting him to say outrageous, insulting things about those who fail to meet up to his “Christian standards. ”
    The few times a year I attend church services, I want to leave with my heart filled with love and my spirit filled with joy. Gay bashing, begging for money and calling Obama a Muslim is not what I’d consider a religious service. Greed and hateful words are not the way Jesus rolled.
    Perhaps the Millennials have the right idea about God. They sample here and there, or maybe just commune with God at the beach on Sunday.
    The refusal to accept the separation of church and state is annoying enough with politicians, but when a minister, priest, or even a Dominican like Ted Cruz’s daddy start dragging politics into their churches and start to tell their parishioners how to vote, it’s worse.
    I think Millennials still have enough youthful brain elasticity to reject shame-based ministries who make them feel angry after the service ends.
    There was a time we never thought about a minister or a congregation’s political affiliations–the topic never came up. Now before I try out a church, first I have to ask what side they’re on. If they are the type who preach right-wing politics from the pulpit, they can include me out. That ain’t Jesus, and neither are they.

  7. It’s St. Paul Square, not St. Paul’s.

    Otherwise, a great article and this aging Flower Child appreciates their appreciation of authenticity. I’m reminded of the Jesus Movement from my youth.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *